I launched on Product Hunt with no audience. Here are the real numbers.
On October 27 I launched Textfold on Product Hunt. It got 5 upvotes and sent 4 people to my website. Here's everything that happened, with the real numbers, and what I'm doing instead.
By Jeyanth, the developer of Textfold ·
Textfold is a text expander for Mac: type ;sig and get your signature in any app. It launched on October 14, and a stranger paid $19 for it six days later. I wrote about that first sale. Product Hunt was meant to be the next step. I had very few followers on X and Threads, and no mailing list.
The numbers
- 5 upvotes and 5 followers on Product Hunt. No comments apart from my own.
- 4 visitors to textfold.app came from Product Hunt.
- 16 downloads in the week of the launch (from 54 to 70 in total). That includes my own test installs and existing users downloading the 1.0.6 update, so new people are fewer than that.
- 0 new sales. Still one customer.
- About 110 views on my launch post on X, my best post so far. Several of the replies came from automated accounts repeating my own words back to me.
Product Hunt mostly rewards makers who already have an audience to bring with them. I didn't, and the numbers show it. That isn't a complaint. It's the most useful thing I learned.
Where visitors actually came from
These are the sites that sent people to textfold.app over the same period:
- Google: 17
- Indie Hackers: 10
- X: 10
- Bing (some of it probably bots): 12
- Facebook groups: 10
- Product Hunt: 4
- Threads: 4
Google sent four times as many people as Product Hunt, mostly to comparison pages and guides like text replacement not working on Mac. Indie Hackers and X came from replying to people, not from posting into the void. The quiet, slow work outperformed the big day.
What I prepared
- A tagline, a description and a first comment, rewritten several times
- Five gallery images and a short video
- A new release, 1.0.6, built from the feedback in my first-sale thread
- Launch posts for X, Threads, LinkedIn and Indie Hackers
- A forum thread on Product Hunt asking what people type over and over
None of it was wasted. The images, video and copy are now on the website, the press kit and every listing I make. The update made the app better. But I spent more time polishing the launch page than talking to people, and the polish didn't bring anyone.
What actually helped this week
One public reply from a stranger. A copywriter looked at my homepage and pointed out that it said “nothing you type leaves your Mac” with no proof and no name behind it. He was right. The next day I added my name and a way to check the claim yourself: watch the app's network traffic with a free firewall like LuLu, and you'll only see update checks and license activation. He then shared the change with his own followers. That one exchange did more for the site than the launch.
Comment threads. Almost every change in 1.0.6 came from people replying to my posts on Indie Hackers: a heads-up before the free limit, a Send Feedback item in the menu, and support reply snippets with fill-in fields.
What I'd do differently
- Launch later. Build a small audience first, then use Product Hunt to reach them all on the same day.
- Spend less time on the page, more on people. Two hours of replying to real questions beats two hours of tweaking gallery images.
- Ignore vote-swap threads. “Share your launch and we'll support you” posts bring votes that count for little and visitors who never try the app.
- Expect bots. Not every reply is a person. The real ones ask a question or mention a detail.
What's next
- More guides people search for, like the ones for editors and support teams.
- Answering “which text expander should I use?” questions where people already ask them.
- The $19 launch price ends on November 8, and Pro goes to $29. That's the first real reason for free users to decide, so I'll learn more from that week than from launch day.
- Another post like this one after November 8, with the numbers, good or bad.
If you've launched something with no audience, I'd love to know what worked for you: hello@textfold.app.